Skip to main content
B.S. Footprint logo
What's Yours?
title=
But we have to pass the bill so that you can find out what is in it, away from the fog of the controversy.  – Nancy Pelosi
more quotes...
  • Home
  • Popular B.S.
  • Sightings
  • Quotations
  • Merch
  • LINK-to-us!
  • Vote Smarter, Not Harder
  • Visual BS
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact us
Home » Blogs » bsfootprint's blog

Collective bargaining PRIVILEGES

Submitted by bsfootprint on Thu, 02/24/2011 - 20:26
bsfootprint's picture

I'm really growing weary of hearing about "collective bargaining rights".

Ahem. They're not rights, they're privileges. They were granted by government, as a result of democratic processes in order to set social policy. Right?

Government Giveth, Government Taketh Away

First, if the government grants something, it's a privilege*. It can be taken away. It's not inalienable. While it's nice to think of it as a right, it's simply not realistic to think that the privilege cannot be taken away, that it is yours forever. Think of it as a collective bargaining license. Like a driver's license**, it's granted by government, and can be restricted or taken away when it's been abused by the recipients.

Second, there is no such thing as a collective right. What is the source of so-called collective rights? The size of the group you are in? If one person doesn't have the right, how can two? Four? Ten? Thousands? It's a fantasy.

Third, it's really strange to see people who normally celebrate democracy and majority rule pushing back so hard when the pendulum swings the other way, when democratic processes lead to outcomes they don't like. (Surely the protesters and their supporters aren't claiming that the Republican majority in Wisconsin wasn't democratically elected, are they?)

* This is the age of the internet. I'm not going to try to explain this, feel free to google search for "rights vs. privileges". Yeah, I know people like to call government-granted privileges rights, but that doesn't make it so.

Addendum

** I'll be only to glad to argue that the state has no legitimate power to prohibit free travel by motor vehicle, that drivers' licenses are a particularly nasty bit of statist evil, but that's another argument for another day. Let's just agree that today, the state wields the power to prohibit your driving a car if you don't have the state's permission, and thus it is a privilege. So if you accept that the state has power, what's so horrible about prohibiting you and a group of like-minded people getting together to bargain for higher wages, and 'strike' (without fear of being fired) if you aren't happy with the way negotiations are going? Once we allow the state to wield arbitrary power in order to set social policy, it's simply a matter of whose policy it sets.

Share this
Filed under
  • The Workplace
  • Hypocrisy
  • WTF?
  • Collective Bargaining
  • Rights vs. Privileges
  • bsfootprint's blog
  • Login to post comments
  • Share this
  • Permalink

Similar Content (auto-generated)

  • Roseanne Barr's Final Solution
  • Income is not wealth
  • Federal Reserve a clear and present danger to economic stability?
  • I am TJIC, and so are you
  • Humor: Anthropogenic Global Warming Defender Flowchart

Recent posts

  • The Road to Serfdom
  • Screwed By Google
  • Hope n' Change Web Comics
  • Obama's unprecedented stance: Supreme Court shouldn...
  • Democracy is the theory that the common people know what...
more

Popular content

Today's:

  • We did better with the nineteenth-century gold standard and passive central banks, with currency boards, or even with 'free banking.'
  • Chart: Gasoline price relative to gold
  • The beauty about [Social Security] is that it is actuarially unsound. Everyone who reaches retirement age is given benefit privileges that far exceed anything he has paid in.

All time:

  • Chart: Gasoline price relative to gold
  • B.S. abounds. Help uncover it.
  • We did better with the nineteenth-century gold standard and passive central banks, with currency boards, or even with 'free banking.'

Last viewed:

  • It's Not Your Money: Senate bill to limit borrowing against 401(k) accounts
  • Chart: Gasoline price relative to gold
  • Bring it all down, man! Vote Democrat
Winner - 2011 Fabulous 50 Blog Awards

BS Merchandise

BS Merchandise
BS Merchandise

Keep the BS Coming!

Your donations help ensure a steady stream of BS.

Subscribe to B.S. Footprint by e-mail

Delivered by FeedBurner

Hawt Links

  • Anti-Wikipedia resource (235)
  • Basic laws of human stupidity (230)
  • Best of the Web Today (217)
  • Big Lies of Science (190)
  • Cargo Cult Science by Richard Feynman (188)
  • Business Insider (178)
  • Dying of Money (PDF) (174)
  • First Tuesday Journal (california real estate) (171)
  • Ric Werme's Guide to Watts Up With That (147)
  • No Dogma (in climate science) (143)
more…
Locations of visitors to this page
Contents copyright © 2009-2012, bsfootprint.com. All rights reserved worldwide. Materials may be reproduced with full attribution and a link back to this site.